Sunday, January 04, 2009

Stop the Zionist genocidal attack on Gaza!




Arms, Medicine and Food for the Palestinian masses!
For International Workers Actions to defeat the Zionist regime!

For more than one week the Israeli Zionist state has bombed and strafed the Gaza Strip causing the worst massacre of the Palestinian people since 1948 in their heroic struggle to liberate their nation from the Zionist occupation. There are more than 500 dead and 3000 injuries most of them non-combatants including women and children.

The Gaza strip is the biggest open air concentration camp in the world. 1.5 million people are crammed into an area of 360 square km. Surrounded by walls and the sea it is a modern version of the Warsaw ghetto under the Nazi occupation of Poland in the Second World War.

For nearly two years, the Zionist state with the support of U.S. imperialism backed by the other imperialist powers, and its local jailers Fatah, have imposed a total blockade on the Gaza strip isolating it from the West Bank of historic Palestine and cutting off gas, electricity and water, as well as food, medicines, etc.

There is little work in Gaza and 90% the population is unemployed. Malnutrition and chronic anemia are rife. For example, most babies born in the last two years and who survived do not grow normally as their mothers and lack food and essential nutrients during the first years of life. 50% of the population are young people under the age of 15 years –that is the generation born since the Oslo Accords in 1993 –and the only thing they know is hunger, and no future but slavery and apartheid.

This slow and cruel genocide is supported and maintained by all the imperialist powers that make up the den of thieves at the UN. It does nothing to stop the bombing or the ground invasion that is now underway that will provoke a even greater slaughter of the masses in Gaza. The new “Republicrat” US President Obama has remained silent so far, tacitly supporting the massacre in Gaza just as he fails to stop the massacres in Afghanistan and Iraq. How could it be otherwise? Obama himself had promised during his election campaign, when he visited the Zionist state of “Israel” and endorsed its occupation of Palestine, to support this “gendarme” of US imperialism in the region.


Obama is the new black face of US imperialism leading its drive to defend its world hegemony against its rivals and fighting more wars to download the costs of its crisis onto the backs of workers

Obama replaces the discredited Bush and offers the "Carrot for the stick". Obama’s "carrots" are new deals to contain the revolutions in the “hotspots” of the world. A new deal between Morales and fascist bourgeoisie in Bolivia; the new deal between Uribe and Chavez to betray the FARC in Colombia; or the new deal with Sarkozy and the Latin American bourgeoisie to restore capitalism in Cuba; or a new deal with the Iranian ayatollahs and the bourgeoisie against Sunni resistance in Iraq. These “carrots” follow the “sticks” such as the military adventures like the Turkish attack on the Kurds in Northern Iraq; the media luna fascists uprising in Bolivia; the attack by Uribe against the FARC in Ecuador; and Saakashvili’s attack on South Ossetia. But in all cases the “carrots” mask the continuous use of the “Republicrat” military actions to mark out the territory and sphere of interests of US imperialism in the face of intensifying inter-imperialist rivalry and the attempt to impose the cost of the capitalist crisis onto the world’s workers and poor peasants.

This is why Obama supports the massacre in Gaza. It is part of the overall US imperialist strategy in the Middle East and Central Asia. Obama has already announced that the US troops will begin withdrawing from Iraq in 2009, and that there will be a build-up of US troops in Afghanistan. The attack on Gaza is part of that plan. Its purpose is to crush the Palestinian resistance, just as the pact with the Iranians and the Turks is to crush the resistance in Iraq. This is to allow the US to withdraw its troops from the Middle East in the hope of avoiding an uprising of the masses. This is the true role of the Zionist state as the US “gendarme” in the Middle East. Thus, this new slaughter of the Palestinian people is one vital part of the new counter-revolutionary plan of the US to extend its sphere of interest into Central Asia over the former Soviet republics including Russia itself, at the expense of its key rivals France and Germany.

Far from bringing an era of "peace" and "democracy" the Republicrat President Obama will act to advance the interests of US imperialism in competition with the other imperialist powers in the EU and Japan, to increase the exploitation and oppression of the peoples to solve the crisis of the bankrupt capitalist world economy and make us pay for the cost of bailing out the banks and the monopolies with unemployment, wage cuts, poverty, starvation and new wars.

Meanwhile, the Zionist state of Israel, by killing hundreds of Palestinians tries to prove to the US that it has overcome its humiliating defeat in the South of Lebanon in 2006, and can earn its money as the “hard cop” of US imperialism in the Middle East. But the Zionist cop also serves the interests of the other imperialist powers. France and Germany have troops in Afghanistan. France and Italy have troops in southern Lebanon under the guise of UN peacekeepers. Japan is dependent for its oil on the Middle East. All the imperialists need to smash the Palestinian resistance, whose heroic liberation struggle is the key to the resistance in all the Middle East.


All the imperialist powers need to download the costs of their crisis onto their own working classes. All need new wars to allow them to get cheap raw materials and labor and drive down labor costs at home. All need to destroy the productive forces including the “destructive” forces of the armaments to increase their profits. The arms monopolists such as Boeing, Northrop Grumman, Lockheed Martin, Raytheon, Westinghouse, General Electric, Airbus and General Dynamics and the big banks that own them such as Citigroup, Morgan Chase and Barclays need to make big superprofits from war to prevent their own bankruptcy in the current crisis.

Fatah and all the Middle East bourgeoisies are accomplices in the genocidal occupation of Palestine by the Zionist state of Israel

The heroic struggle of the Palestine peoples over decades against the Zionist occupation have been suppressed with the complicity of the Palestinian bourgeoisie. The second Intifada was crushed by mid-2002 by the tanks of Sharon and Bush, and the “roadmap” agreed by the United States, Russia and the UN giving the “Palestinian Authority”, led by Fatah, the role of administering and policing the Bantustan concentration camps in Gaza and the West Bank. These camps served to supply a reserve army of cheap labor to the Israel factories and businesses.

In Gaza, in February 2008, a heroic uprising toppled the wall at Rafah to break the siege and get access to vital food and medicines. At the same time the Palestinians opened up the possibility of uniting their struggle with their class brothers and sisters in Egypt. To put a stop to this Mubarak sent his army to help Hamas to rebuild the wall. This failure to unite the fight at this time proved to the Zionists that they could risk planning for an all out destruction of the resistance in Gaza six months later.

It is the result of the collaboration of Fatah and Hamas with Israel, as junior partners in the rule of imperialism, that has allowed the Zionists to launch their bombings and to carry out the threat of a ground war that will repeat the massacre such as Sabra and Shatila in Lebanon in 1982. Fatah has become a direct collaborators of the Zionist state paid to manage the concentration camps. They are jailers and slaveholders of their own people!

Again in 2006, with the humiliating defeat of the Zionist army by the masses in the south of Lebanon, could have been used to stop the plan for the Bantustans on the West Bank and the ghetto in Gaza. But the leaders of Hezbollah, turned its back on this struggle and made a deal with the pro-imperialist Siniora to share the profits of the reconstruction of Lebanon, agreed to the imperialist UN troops to protect the border of Israel and allowed the Zionist state to prepare for its slaughter in Gaza. Thus, Fatah and Hezbollah are the accomplices of Israel in dividing and weakening the most advanced sections of the Palestinian masses in the face of the plan to destroy all resistance to the Zionist occupation.

Under these conditions the truce that Hamas made with the Zionist occupying troops could not but end up as a new massacre of the Palestinians. But it is not only Fatah, Hezbollah and Hamas that collaborate with the Zionist state. All the national bourgeoisies of the Middle East whether they collaborate with Anglo-US, French, German or Japanese imperialism, are responsible for the oppression of the Palestinian people. They are today the accomplices of the new Bush/Obama genocidal attack by the Zionist state on Gaza.

Mubarak in Egypt was the first to recognize the State of Israel and tightly controls the southern and western borders of Gaza Strip, locking the Palestinian people in the ghetto and preventing them from joining forces with exploited and oppressed Egyptian workers! In Jordan the bourgeoisie and the monarchy rule over the Palestinians on the East bank of the Jordan where in 1970 King Hussein suppressed an uprising of the Palestinians in their refugee camps on what is called "black September".

For the defeat of the murdering Zionist army! For the victory of the Palestinian working class resistance!

The proletariat cannot allow this counterrevolutionary plan to succeed. It is necessary to defeat the invading Zionist army. Either the Zionist army is defeated and with it the plans of the imperialists led by Bush/Obama, or the Palestinian resistance will be smashed, not only in Gaza, but in the West Bank, and the Zionist state will feel empowered to take control of southern Lebanon. This is what the imperialist powers and the Zionist state of Israel are planning to make the working class of the whole Middle East as well as the heroic resistance Iraq and Afghanistan suffer a terrible defeat.

Since Hamas won the elections in February 2006 in Gaza, it has made truces in the hope of doing a deal with Israel to get funds to administer Gaza as a ghetto in the same way that Fatah is paid to administer the West Bank. This strategy of military threat to win political advantages proves that Hamas has taken over the role of Fatah after the Palestinian people in Gaza rose up in 2006 to throw it out with its police and spies, openly collaborating with Israel.

The endless martyrdom of the Palestinian people proves that submission of the working class to their “own” bourgeois always ends in tragedy. The national bourgeoisies that control the Palestinian people and the masses of the Middle East can never lead the Palestinian people to national liberation. The national revolution threatens their class interests as the junior business partners of various imperialist powers. Therefore the national revolution can only succeed when it is led by the self-organised working class and their organizations for which there is no possibility of being bribed by the occupying Zionist state.

Such a victory is necessary since workers will never be able to live, eat and work without the military defeat of the Zionist state which bombs and murders to maintain its occupation of historic Palestine.

  • Enough! The martyred Palestinian people of Gaza cannot remain isolated!
  • We must kick out the UN troops from the south of Lebanon to unite the Palestinian people with the victorious masses of southern Lebanon!
  • Disarm the Fatah police that collaborate with Israel to jail their own people! Distribute these weapons to the masses of the West Bank, Gaza and southern Lebanon! A gun for every fighter!
  • We have to organize the millions of Palestinian exiles in Jordan!
  • For an Assembly of Palestinian workers and peasants delegates with the authority to call for the arming of the people and the destruction of the Zionist state of Israel!

The most powerful weapon to stop the planned slaughter is the uprising of the Palestinian masses to break down the walls of Gaza, and to destroy the walls of the West Bank and unite with the working class of Egypt to launch a joint struggle for bread, land and national independence!


For a revolutionary uprising of the Palestinian and Arab masses of Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan and the entire region to defeat imperialism and its gendarme Zionist Israel!


Faced with the new Zionist state genocidal attack, we stand unconditionally in the same trench of the Palestinian people their organizations such as Hamas other militias resisting the Zionist invaders. Enough with impotent words and the "Intifada" based on the isolation and lack of arms of the people.

But while we fight alongside Hamas against the Israeli state we do not give any political support to the bourgeois leadership Hamas. We say that the liberation of the Palestinian people from the Zionist occupation can only come from a united struggle of the masses of all the Middle East. It is the same revolutionary struggle that today is divided by the walls that separate the Palestinians of occupied Palestine from their class brothers and sisters in the Lebanon and Jordan and all over the Middle East. That is the first wall to be broken down, that which subjugates these workers to their respective national bourgeoisies.

The heroism of the Palestinian Intifada of 2000-2001 stands as an example for the world to see! But the victory of the Palestinian cause, to destroy the Zionist state and to complete the struggle for national liberation, is not only the task of the oppressed Palestinian people. Only a revolutionary upheaval of the exploited masses of the Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt, Syria and all the Middle East can lead to the heroic victory of the Palestinian people.

  • Weapons, food and medicine to Gaza!
  • One working class, one anti-imperialist and anti-capitalist struggle throughout the Middle East!
  • Down with the walls of shame and oppression built by imperialism, the Zionist state and the national bourgeoisies: that is the way to unite the whole proletariat of the region!
  • The victory of the Palestinian masses is in the hands of the international working class!
  • Strike against all those imperialist transnationals that profit from the Zionist occupation of Palestine! Into the streets to support our Palestinian brothers and sisters!

Workers and the exploited of the world must stand in defense of the martyred people Palestine. Hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are mobilizing for their brothers and sisters in Gaza –in the West Bank, Lebanon, Egypt and Jordan. At the heart the Europe are Palestinian migrant workers, Arabs and African workers who are working in Spain, France, England, Denmark, Italy, Turkey, etc. These migrant workers are oppressed by vicious laws that can deport them or put them in jail.


While the Palestinian people continue being massacred and their nation remains occupied, while the imperialist forces continue occupying and killing in Iraq and Afghanistan, we must transform the rallying cry of the youth workers of the French Cités of 2005: "Every night we make Paris a Baghdad" into our battle flag to unite the exploited and oppressed all over Europe!

The heroic youth and worker rebels of Greece who have responded to the bankruptcy of the global capitalist imperialist economy and the brutal attack of the exploiters, with a magnificent revolt that threatens to re-open the road to revolution in Europe after 30 years, are showing the way for workers all over the world to stand up and fight back.

In the States United, the dockworkers of the Local 10 of the ILWU in Oakland, have shown how to take strike action against the war in Iraq and Afghanistan, and have two comrades facing jail as a result. They have the authority to lead the US working class to break with Bush/Obama "Republicrat" regime and the bureaucracy of the AFL-CIO, and strike in support of their class brothers and sisters under attack by genocidal Zionist State Israel.

In Europe, Africa, Asia, USA, Latin America we need to take to the streets with demonstrations, strikes, boycotts and working class action to stop the genocidal attack of Bush/Obama and the Zionist state of Israel!

  • The working class must ban all shipments of arms, materiel and ammunition to the genocidal Zionist state and guarantee shipments of weapons, ammunition, medicines and food to the Palestinian people!
  • From Athens to Madrid, from Moscow to London, from Beijing to Islamabad, from Johannesburg to Damascus, from New York to Santiago and from Alaska to the Tierra del Fuego, the workers and exploited of the world must stand united with the working class and oppressed people of Palestine!
  • For a workers and farmers government of a non-racist, secular and democratic Palestine!
  • For a Federation of Socialist Republics of the Middle East!

International Secretariat or Coordination and Action (SCAI) of the Leninist Trotskyist Fraction
Internationalist Workers Party (POI - CI, Chile)
Communist Workers Group (CWG, New Zealand),
Internationalist Workers League (LOI - CI, Argentina)
Internationalist Trotskyist League (LTI, Peru),
Internationalist Trotskyist League (LTI, Bolivia)
Trotskyist Fraction (FT, Brazil).

Translated and edited by CWG

3 comments:

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
dave said...

[posted for Yossi Schwartz]

Comrade Brown

I read your statement very carefully and while I like many parts of it at the same time I have many criticism of the statement. For example your lack of understanding of fascism and your theory of Cuba as a workers state. I will however focus narrowly on two main problems in your statements in the context of the actual war.

A- THE CONFUSION BETWEEN THE WILL OF HAMAS AND HEZBOLLAH TO MAKE A DEAL WITH US AND ISRAEL AND MAKING AN ACTUAL DEAL.

You repeat many times that Hamas is like Fatah and like Mubarak working with imperialism and the Israeli state against the Arab masses imposing the blockade together etc.

It is a fact that Hamas for a few years is sending signals of its willingness to collaborate with the imperialists and reach a modus vivendi with Israel . However the US and Israel and the European imperialists have rejected it. As a matter of fact this particular war is an attempt to mold Hamas into the same role as Abu Mazen's Fatah is playing. If Hamas was playing the same role like Fatah Israel would have not fone to a war against it with the support of the Security council of the UN.

It is not very useful to exaggerate and see only one side of reality.

You yourself are forced to recognize reality not only when you say that it is necessary to have a military block with Hamas but without giving it political support, which we agree, but by calling to disarm Abu Mazen police force while you do not call for the same regarding Hamas armed militia you admit that your characterization of the actual role of Hamas is wrong.

To make things worse you give the impression that Hamas can win in the war and you call for its victory. In reality only working class revolution can defeat Israel and unfortunately as result of your approach you do not raise the slogan for a revolutionary victory for the Palestinians and revolutionary defeat or Israel.

Not only this but were you serious in your charges of Hamas how can you have a military block with them when they are actually betraying the masses?

Even worse is your use of the demand of a workers government as an expression of two stage revolution. :

You wrote many sentences about the masses and the heroic mass struggle etc. However your writing does not reflect Trotsky's theory of the Permanent Revolution.

You do not speak of the need of the working class to shoulder the democratic tasks and lead the masses nor do you speak of the need for a working class revolutionary party . The masses is not equal the working class and clearly not equal the consciousness working class-the vanguard.

You raise the demand :

For a workers and farmers government of a non-racist, secular and democratic Palestine

This slogan in the way you raise it is wrong as it raise the workers government in abstract On whom do you call to form such a government?

It gives a very strong impression that you are for two stage revolution and the first one is a secular democratic Palestine i.e a Bourgeois state

I am attaching me notes for you to read..

One of the more leftist position on the Zionist war on the Palestinian people in Gaza is of the group CWG and the other groups that signed together the declaration

Stop the Zionist genocidal attack on Gaza . Yet We think that this position is in contradiction to Trotsky's theory of the Permanent revolution.

It began with a statement that we agree with namely


"Israel is causing the worst massacre of the Palestinian people since 1948 in their heroic struggle to liberate their nation from the Zionist occupation. There are more than 400 dead and 2000 injuries most of them non-combatants including women and children ( By now more than 500 death and more than 2400 injuries)."

That "The Gaza strip is the biggest open air concentration camp in the world. 1.5 million people are crammed into an area of 360 square km. Surrounded by walls and the sea it is a modern version of the Warsaw ghetto under the Nazi occupation of Poland in the Second World War."

That "For nearly two years, the Zionist state with the support of U.S. imperialism backed by the other imperialist powers, and its local jailers Fatah, have imposed a total blockade on the Gaza strip isolating it from the West Bank of historic Palestine and cutting off gas, electricity and water, as well as food, medicines, etc."

"There is little work in Gaza and 90% the population is unemployed. Malnutrition and chronic anemia are rife. For example, most babies born in the last two years and who survived do not grow normally as their mothers and lack food and essential nutrients during the first years of life. 50% of the population are young people under the age of 15 years –that is the generation born since the Oslo Accords in 1993 –and the only thing they know is hunger, and no future but slavery and apartheid."

"This slow and cruel genocide is supported and maintained by all the imperialist powers that make up the den of thieves at the UN. It does nothing to stop the bombing or the ground invasion that is now underway that will provoke a even greater slaughter of the masses in Gaza . The new “Republicrat” US President Obama has remained silent so far, tacitly supporting the massacre in Gaza just as he fails to stop the massacres in Afghanistan and Iraq . How could it be otherwise? Obama himself had promised during his election campaign, when he visited the Zionist state of “ Israel ” and endorsed its occupation of Palestine , to support this “gendarme” of US imperialism in the region."

"Obama is the new black face of US imperialism leading its drive to defend its world hegemony against its rivals and fighting more wars to download the costs of its crisis onto the backs of workers."

.....

We have some problems with the next paragraph :

"Obama replaces the discredited Bush and offers the "Carrot for the stick". Obama’s "carrots" are new deals to contain the revolutions in the “hotspots” of the world. A new deal between Morales and fascist bourgeoisie in Bolivia; the new deal between Uribe and Chavez to betray the FARC in Colombia; or the new deal with Sarkozy and the Latin American bourgeoisie to restore capitalism in Cuba; or a new deal with the Iranian ayatollahs and the bourgeoisie against Sunni resistance in Iraq. These “carrots” follow the “sticks” such as the military adventures like the Turkish attack on the Kurds in Northern Iraq; the media luna fascists uprising in Bolivia; the attack by Uribe against the FARC in Ecuador; and Saakashvili’s attack on South Ossetia. But in all cases the “carrots” mask the continuous use of the “Republicrat” military actions to mark out the territory and sphere of interests of US imperialism in the face of intensifying inter-imperialist rivalry and the attempt to impose the cost of the capitalist crisis onto the world’s workers and poor peasants."

While we accept that in general the assesement is correct we do not like the designation of the Bourgeoisie in Bolivia as fascists.

Fascism is a petit bourgeois movement coming to power from below. It is the Jacobins 200 years later as Trotsky wrote. It is important to differentiate between right wing governments and fascist government and movements and those who can not understand the difference will not be able to fight the real fascists.

We have a real difference on the class nature of Cuba and we do not think the petit bourgeois guerrillas can replace the working class and form a workers state ( albeit deformed or degenerated)

Furthermore we think that there is a confusion between a will to make a deal with imperialism and a deal that was done with imperialism. This for example is the case with Iran reactionary government that wants to make a deal with US imperialism but the US commitment to Israel is on the way of such a deal. It is one thing to warn of such a deal and another to say that it is done.

The same is true with Hamas. For a few years Hamas wants to make a deal with Israel and indicated tha it is ready to recognize Israel de facto. However Israel is not ready for such a deal and for this reason there is a military clash. And for this reason it is necessary to call for a military block with Hamas without giving it any political support. It would be much better to criticize Hamas for not arming the workers the unemployed most of them and the poor peasants.

It is necessary as well to criticize Hamas for attacking Israeli settlements in the Negev which helps the Zionist state to rationalized its genocide in terms of defending the children of Sderoth.

Similarely it is much better to criticize Hugo Chavez for his line on the war between Israel and the people of Gaza .

We agree with the following statements:

"This is why Obama supports the massacre in Gaza. It is part of the overall US imperialist strategy in the Middle East and Central Asia. Obama has already announced that the US troops will begin withdrawing from Iraq in 2009, and that there will be a build-up of US troops in Afghanistan. The attack on Gaza is part of that plan. Its purpose is to crush the Palestinian resistance, just as the pact with the Iranians and the Turks is to crush the resistance in Iraq. This is to allow the US to withdraw its troops from the Middle East in the hope of avoiding an uprising of the masses. This is the true role of the Zionist state as the US “gendarme” in the Middle East. Thus, this new slaughter of the Palestinian people is one vital part of the new counter-revolutionary plan of the US to extend its sphere of interest into Central Asia over the former Soviet republics including Russia itself, at the expense of its key rivals France and Germany."

"Far from bringing an era of "peace" and "democracy" the Republicrat President Obama will act to advance the interests of US imperialism in competition with the other imperialist powers in the EU and Japan, to increase the exploitation and oppression of the peoples to solve the crisis of the bankrupt capitalist world economy and make us pay for the cost of bailing out the banks and the monopolies with unemployment, wage cuts, poverty, starvation and new wars."

"Meanwhile, the Zionist state of Israel, by killing hundreds of Palestinians tries to prove to the US that it has overcome its humiliating defeat in the South of Lebanon in 2006, and can earn its money as the “hard cop” of US imperialism in the Middle East. But the Zionist cop also serves the interests of the other imperialist powers. France and Germany have troops in Afghanistan . France and Italy have troops in southern Lebanon under the guise of UN peacekeepers. Japan is dependent for its oil on the Middle East. All the imperialists need to smash the Palestinian resistance, whose heroic liberation struggle is the key to the resistance in all the Middle East."

"All the imperialist powers need to download the costs of their crisis onto their own working classes. All need new wars to allow them to get cheap raw materials and labor and drive down labor costs at home. All need to destroy the productive forces including the “destructive” forces of the armaments to increase their profits. The arms monopolists such as Boeing, Northrop Grumman, Lockheed Martin, Raytheon, Westinghouse, General Electric, Airbus and General Dynamics and the big banks that own them such as Citigroup, Morgan Chase and Barclays need to make big superprofits from war to prevent their own bankruptcy in the current crisis."


We agree that: "Fatah and all the Middle East bourgeoisies are accomplices in the genocidal occupation of Palestine by the Zionist state of Israel...
The heroic struggle of the Palestine peoples over decades against the Zionist occupation have been suppressed with the complicity of the Palestinian bourgeoisie. The second Intifada was crushed by mid-2002 by the tanks of Sharon and Bush, and the “roadmap” agreed by the United States , Russia and the UN giving the “Palestinian Authority”, led by Fatah, the role of administering and policing the Bantustan concentration camps in Gaza and the West Bank. These camps served to supply a reserve army of cheap labor to the Israel factories and businesses."

"In Gaza , in February 2008, a heroic uprising toppled the wall at Rafah to break the siege and get access to vital food and medicines. At the same time the Palestinians opened up the possibility of uniting their struggle with their class brothers and sisters in Egypt."

We have a problem with the following point that put Mubarak and Hamas on the same plan.

"To put a stop to this Mubarak sent his army to help Hamas to rebuild the wall. This failure to unite the fight at this time proved to the Zionists that they could risk planning for an all out destruction of the resistance in Gaza six months later...It is the result of the collaboration of Fatah and Hamas with Israel, as junior partners in the rule of imperialism, that has allowed the Zionists to launch their bombings and to carry out the threat of a ground war that will repeat the massacre such as Sabra and Shatila in Lebanon in 1982. Fatah has become a direct collaborators of the Zionist state paid to manage the concentration camps. They are jailers and slaveholders of their own people!"

As I wrote earlier you are confusing the will to act as a policeman with the actual role of acting as a policeman. It was Hamas activists who blew up the walls.

It seems to us that you are not very good in dealing with contradictions and you want to see black and white yes no all the time.

We agree with your next point:

"Again in 2006, with the humiliating defeat of the Zionist army by the masses in the south of Lebanon , could have been used to stop the plan for the Bantustans on the West Bank and the ghetto in Gaza . But the leaders of Hezbollah, turned its back on this struggle and made a deal with the pro-imperialist Siniora to share the profits of the reconstruction of Lebanon, agreed to the imperialist UN troops to protect the border of Israel and allowed the Zionist state to prepare for its slaughter in Gaza."

We have a problem with your conclusion that put Fatah that actually collaborate with Israel and Hezbullah and Hamas that are not revolutionaries but did not collaboarate with Israel and we can not agree with the statement:

"Thus, Fatah and Hezbollah are the accomplices of Israel in dividing and weakening the most advanced sections of the Palestinian masses in the face of the plan to destroy all resistance to the Zionist occupation."

We can not agree with:

" Under these conditions the truce that Hamas made with the Zionist occupying troops could not but end up as a new massacre of the Palestinians. But it is not only Fatah, Hezbollah and Hamas that collaborate with the Zionist state.All the national bourgeoisies of the Middle East whether they collaborate with Anglo-US, French, German or Japanese imperialism, are responsible for the oppression of the Palestinian people. They are today the accomplices of the new Bush/Obama genocidal attack by the Zionist state on Gaza."

Hamas needed the time to rebuild its military strength. The problem was not with a six months cease fire but with the fact that Hamas is a reactionary organization afraid of the masses wasted this time instead of using it to arm the masses in gaza . And we can not agree to putting Egypt and Abu Mazen and on the other hand Hamas on the same plan..

We agree with:

"Mubarak in Egypt was the first to recognize the State of Israel and tightly controls the southern and western borders of Gaza Strip, locking the Palestinian people in the ghetto and preventing them from joining forces with exploited and oppressed Egyptian workers! In Jordan the bourgeoisie and the monarchy rule over the Palestinians on the East bank of the Jordan where in 1970 King Hussein suppressed an uprising of the Palestinians in their refugee camps on what is called "black September"."

"For the defeat of the murdering Zionist army! For the victory of the Palestinian working class resistance!"

We agree with:

"The proletariat cannot allow this counterrevolutionary plan to succeed. It is necessary to defeat the invading Zionist army. Either the Zionist army is defeated and with it the plans of the imperialists led by Bush/Obama, or the Palestinian resistance will be smashed, not only in Gaza , but in the West Bank, and the Zionist state will feel empowered to take control of southern Lebanon . This is what the imperialist powers and the Zionist state of Israel are planning to make the working class of the whole Middle East as well as the heroic resistance Iraq and Afghanistan suffer a terrible defeat."

I already explained why we can not agree with the statement that we quote the will to betrayal that we should warn the masses from and actual deal and thus we do not accept the following point:

"Since Hamas won the elections in February 2006 in Gaza, it has made truces in the hope of doing a deal with Israel to get funds to administer Gaza as a ghetto in the same way that Fatah is paid to administer the West Bank. This strategy of military threat to win political advantages proves that Hamas has taken over the role of Fatah after the Palestinian people in Gaza rose up in 2006 to throw it out with its police and spies, openly collaborating with Israel."

We agree with the point that:

"The endless martyrdom of the Palestinian people proves that submission of the working class to their “own” bourgeois always ends in tragedy. The national bourgeoisies that control the Palestinian people and the masses of the Middle East can never lead the Palestinian people to national liberation. The national revolution threatens their class interests as the junior business partners of various imperialist powers. Therefore the national revolution can only succeed when it is led by the self-organised working class and their organizations for which there is no possibility of being bribed by the occupying Zionist state...Such a victory is necessary since workers will never be able to live, eat and work without the military defeat of the Zionist state which bombs and murders to maintain its occupation of historic Palestine."

We think it should say without the revolutionary defeat of the Zionist state as your line implies the possibility of Hamas to military defeat Israel which is impossibility. To defeat Israel it can be done only by Arab working class revolution.

The most important criticism we have of your line is that you limit your vision to the national liberation of Palestine rather than the struggle for the working class to shoulder the democratic tasks that can be full filled when the working class take power in the form of a workers state.

The following part of your statement shows that you are forced to distinquish between the role of Abu Mazen-Fatah and Hamas as you do not call to disarm Hamas fighters like your call to disarm Abu Mazen police force. You are calling instead for a military block without political support. We agree with this call but we think that by raising the possibility that Hamas can win a military victory against Israel you are falling into a form of a political support for Hamas:

"Enough! The martyred Palestinian people of Gaza cannot remain isolated!

We must kick out the UN troops from the south of Lebanon to unite the Palestinian people with the victorious masses of southern Lebanon!

Disarm the Fatah police that collaborate with Israel to jail their own people! Distribute these weapons to the masses of the West Bank, Gaza and southern Lebanon ! A gun for every fighter!

We have to organize the millions of Palestinian exiles in Jordan!

For an Assembly of Palestinian workers and peasants delegates with the authority to call for the arming of the people and the destruction of the Zionist state of Israel!

The most powerful weapon to stop the planned slaughter is the uprising of the Palestinian masses to break down the walls of Gaza , and to destroy the walls of the West Bank and unite with the working class of Egypt to launch a joint struggle for bread, land and national independence!

For a revolutionary uprising of the Palestinian and Arab masses of Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan and the entire region to defeat imperialism and its gendarme Zionist Israel!

Faced with the new Zionist state genocidal attack, we stand unconditionally in the same trench of the Palestinian people their organizations such as Hamas other militias resisting the Zionist invaders. Enough with impotent words and the "Intifada" based on the isolation and lack of arms of the people.

But while we fight alongside Hamas against the Israeli state we do not give any political support to the bourgeois leadership Hamas. We say that the liberation of the Palestinian people from the Zionist occupation can only come from a united struggle of the masses of all the Middle East . It is the same revolutionary struggle that today is divided by the walls that separate the Palestinians of occupied Palestine from their class brothers and sisters in the Lebanon and Jordan and all over the Middle East . That is the first wall to be broken down, that which subjugates these workers to their respective national bourgeoisies."


We agree with your point that:

"The heroism of the Palestinian revolution 2000-2001 stands as an example for the world to see! But the victory of the Palestinian cause, to destroy the Zionist state and to complete the struggle for national liberation, is not only the task of the oppressed Palestinian people. Only a revolutionary upheaval of the exploited masses of the Lebanon , Jordan , Egypt , Syria and all the Middle East can lead to the heroic victory of the Palestinian people."

However with is missing is a class content the working class is not the same as the masses in general and it must be the working class at the head of the masses led by the revolutionary working class party to win the revolutionary struggle and this is vague at best in your statement.

It is very good that you are calling for Internationalism in Action:

"Weapons, food and medicine to Gaza!

One working class, one anti-imperialist and anti-capitalist struggle throughout the Middle East!

Down with the walls of shame and oppression built by imperialism, the Zionist state and the national bourgeoisies: that is the way to unite the whole proletariat of the region!

The victory of the Palestinian masses is in the hands of the international working class!

Strike against all those imperialist transnationals that profit from the Zionist occupation of Palestine ! Into the streets to support our Palestinian brothers and sisters!

Workers and the exploited of the world must stand in defense of the martyred people Palestine. Hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are mobilizing for their brothers and sisters in Gaza –in the West Bank, Lebanon , Egypt and Jordan . At the heart the Europe are Palestinian migrant workers, Arabs and African workers who are working in Spain , France , England , Denmark , Italy , Turkey , etc. These migrant workers are oppressed by vicious laws that can deport them or put them in jail.

While the Palestinian people continue being massacred and their nation remains occupied, while the imperialist forces continue occupying and killing in Iraq and Afghanistan, we must transform the rallying cry of the youth workers of the French Cités of 2005: "Every night we make Paris a Baghdad" into our battle flag to unite the exploited and oppressed all over Europe!

The heroic youth and worker rebels of Greece who have responded to the bankruptcy of the global capitalist imperialist economy and the brutal attack of the exploiters, with a magnificent revolt that threatens to re-open the road to revolution in Europe after 30 years, are showing the way for workers all over the world to stand up and fight back.

In the States United, the dockworkers of the Local 10 of the ILWU in Oakland, have shown how to take strike action against the war in Iraq and Afghanistan, and have two comrades facing jail as a result. They have the authority to lead the US working class to break with Bush/Obama "Republicrat" regime and the bureaucracy of the AFL-CIO, and strike in support of their class brothers and sisters under attack by genocidal Zionist State Israel.

In Europe, Africa, Asia, USA, Latin America we need to take to the streets with demonstrations, strikes, boycotts and working class action to stop the genocidal attack of Bush/Obama and the Zionist state of Israel!

The working class must ban all shipments of arms, materiel and ammunition to the genocidal Zionist state and guarantee shipments of weapons, ammunition, medicines and food to the Palestinian people!

From Athens to Madrid, from Moscow to London, from Beijing to Islamabad, from Johannesburg to Damascus, from New York to Santiago and from Alaska to the Tierra del Fuego, the workers and exploited of the world must stand united with the working class and oppressed people of Palestine."

Your most important slogan is:

"For a workers and farmers government of a non-racist, secular and democratic Palestine"

This slogan is wrong as it raises the workers government in abstract on whom do you call to form such a government?

It gives a very strong impression that you are for two stage revolution and the first one is a secular democratic Palestine (Bourgeois state)!

"For a Federation of Socialist Republics of the Middle East!

dave said...

Comrade Yossi,

Thanks for your detailed comment.

Two questions stand out.

The character of Hamas and the Workers and Farmers Government.

You agree that our position of military support for Hamas against Israel, but with absolutely no political support, is correct.

So we can advocate to fight alongside them against Israel in a military bloc, but criticise them at the same time as a bourgeois faction that sooner or later will turn on and defeat the workers.

I agree that to criticise Hamas for something it has or has not done falsely, especially when it is under massive attack by Israel such as is the case now, prevents us from gaining the ear of ordinary Palestinians. It would also be suicidal.

For example, it is our understanding that Hamas did rebuild the wall at Rafah after it was broken down in Feb 08. You say that Hamas itself broke the wall down.
We will check our facts on that because if we were present alongside Hamas then we would certainly have helped pull the wall down.

You say we should consider Hamas and Fatah differently because Hamas is fighting Israel, and that we do actually by calling for a military bloc with them. But we would do the same if Fatah changed its position and fought Israel.

Surely the point is that even if one faction is fighting while the other is not, they are still bourgeois factions whose objective is to trade Palestine independence for a bourgeois Palestine colony.

On the second question of our demand:

"For a workers and farmers government of a non-racist, secular and democratic Palestine!"

You say it could appear to support a two stage theory of first a bourgeois democratic republic and then second a socialist republic.

For us the formulation of "a workers and farmers government" is the same as a socialist government.
It is the formulation Trotsky used in the Transitional Program. Maybe we should say socialist as well, as we certainly do in the following demand:

"For a Federation of Socialist Republics of the Middle East!"

fraternally
Dave Brown